2011 - Sheila Larson's Revenge
- December 27, 2011: Tom's Cousin Sherm [Tall Tales]
- December 20, 2011: Darren, PBR, Gene Simmons, Marky Ramone, Glenn Danzig, Zachary Brimstead, Darren, Old Man Dalrymple, Bryce [Consolidated Party] (0:28)
- December 13, 2011: Mark Remington [Music Critic], David Quinnfelder [Reclusive Genius]
- December 6, 2011: Philly Boy Roy [Returns to En-guh-land] (1:48)
- November 29, 2011: No Appearance
- November 22, 2011: No Appearance
- November 15, 2011: Ross Fryhinkel [Movie Premiere] (ibid)
- November 8, 2011: Joff [Celebrity Friends]
- November 1: Darren from Work [Halloween]
- October 25, 2011: That's Not Coffee (early), Skip Dworkin [Newbridge Dance Party]
- October 18, 2011: No Best Show
- October 11, 2011: PBR [Bad Sports Week] (1:29)
- October 4, 2011: Trip Whiting [Time Trampoline]
- September 27, 2011: Darren [Shot by Sheila]
- September 20, 2011: Matthew Tompkins [It's Time To Shout]
- September 13, 2011: Rich (Newbridge High Reunion]
- September 6, 2011: PBR [Mayor Courtesy Call] (2:08)
- August 30, 2011: No Best Show
- August 23, 2011: Blaze Monroe [You Got Blazed]
- August 16, 2011: PBR [The Ban] (1:50)
- August 9, 2011: Brent Prefontaine [Buzz Consultant]
- August 2, 2011: No Best Show
- July 26, 2011: No Appearance
- July 19, 2011: No Appearance
- July 12, 2011: Mr. First [Ron Furst]
- July 5, 2011: Philly Boy Roy [Ziegler Family Family Water Show] (2:04)
- June 28, 2011: Darren [Quicksand]
- June 21, 2011: No Appearance
- June 14, 2011: No Appearance
- June 7, 2011: Warden [TV Shows]
- May 31, 2011: No Appearance
- May 24, 2011: No Appearance
- May 17, 2011: Gene Simmons [Lisa Jane Persky]
- May 10, 2011: Darren from Work [Ploptron 5000], Darren Calls Back [Explosion] (2:29)
- May 3, 2011: No Best Show
- April 26, 2011: Herb Wilkinson [Hardcore Gangs]
- April 19, 2011: Myron Felkerton (Business Secrets Revealed)
- April 12, 2011: No Appearance
- April 5, 2011: No Appearance
- March 29, 2011: PBR [Spoken Word] (0:31)
- March 22, 2011: Magic Todd Mannheim [Newbridge High Basketball], Miracle Worker [Todd's Dad]
- March 15, 2011: Robert Monroe [Tom's Congressman] ()
- March 8, 2011: Philly Boy Roy [Going to Die] (2:09)
- March 1, 2011: Gene Simmons [Ted Leo and Carl Newman] ()
- February 22, 2011: No Appearance
- February 15, 2011: Pledge Two Weeks Early [You Fart] ()
- February 8, 2011: Rick von Gilderschmidt [I'm Egyptian] ()
- February 1, 2011: No Best Show
- January 25, 2011: Matthew Tompkins from Shout [Aziz Ansari, et al] ()
- January 18, 2011: Mike Mannheim [QB for Monday Night Miracle] ()
- January 11, 2011: Philly Boy Roy [Siamese Twins] (1:49)
- January 4, 2011: Vern [Yearies] ()
